Love Is Not Always Enough

By Emma Pearson

May 25, 2024

Image by freestocks on Unsplash

5 March 2023

Last night I saw “The Son”, which I knew would be a hard film.

(** Spoiler Alerts ** Don’t read if you want to see the film **)

I knew from the trailer that it was about teenage struggle – possibly linked to mental health issues related to loss, gender- or sexual-orientation, or other. I suspected, also from the trailer, that there’d be a suicide attempt. And I could tell from the trailer that the acting – particularly by Hugh Jackman – would be superlative. Added to that, that Anthony Hopkins, with his fierce and majestic beauty, his piercing blue eyes, and his dulcet Welsh tones, also performed in it, meant that it was “une évidence” that I’d make time to see it.

So off I popped to see it with Medjool. Only our second film of the weekend!

The film WAS hard to watch.

It IS a good film.

The film is getting good reviews.

The film does tackle mental health well, and seriously.

And yet…, I felt strangely unaffected by it.

A little bit later, while we were slurping our Udon Noodle soup, Medjool asked if I wanted to talk about it.

“No – not really”.

But immediately, I wondered, “why don’t I?”

Sometimes I need space and time after watching a film before I can begin to discuss, explore, excavate its inner impact. Sometimes I can do it straight away. Sometimes I can’t ever go back over it. And sometimes, the film doesn’t warrant it.

But for this film – I just felt strangely dissociated. Disconnected. Almost unmoved.

Or rather, split.

I felt moved as a viewer. As an observer. As a bog-standard member of the audience.

I was profoundly moved by the young boy’s experience of being so lost in his world. By the estranged parents’ sense of powerlessness in making any of his experience better for him.

But considering so much of this story overlapped with so much of my story, I thought I would be more affected as a mum-viewer. As a mum who has a child with depression. As a mum (or parent) struggling alone to understand her child’s inner world. As a parent who can appreciate the enormity of what her child has lost in life, and can do zippo to make any of it better.

The film just couldn’t reach me though – not in that way.

And I am curious why.

Medjool and I did talk about it. I have reflected further on it.

I think that, in part, I just can’t go there. There’s way too much of my own much pain and grief and loss for me to not be capable – consciously or unconsciously – of expending surplus energy on a film that – while surely based on myriad real lives – is not in and of itself a “true story”.

I think mostly though the film simply didn’t reflect “my story”. Too many of the details were alien. Wrong. Out of whack.

Both parents were alive in the film – if also divorced.

Not my story.

The boy had choice as to where to live. With dad or with mum.

Not my story.

The dad was particularly useless at listening, exploring, asking questions, showing interest in his child.

Not my story. (Oh – how I wanted to shake him, to slap him, to get him to just SHUT UP and listen to his child).

And of course, the gun.

Not my story.

The mother was so full of angst and fear, still reeling from the loss of her husband.

Okay – a bit more my story. Even if her loss was divorce and my loss was death.

And the horrendous inevitability of it all. The knowing. The seeing what was bound to happen way before it did, in slow motion, scene by scene, pixel by pixel. Feeling that perhaps I might reach into the screen and put up my hand to stop the inevitable from happening.

My ability to read so much into every single word the young lad said to his parents.

Right down to the “You don’t deserve this”, and “I love you so much”.

That part – that was definitely my story.

If not when it was actually the story I was living.

If not when I was living into that story, in that moment.

In the film, I saw it all before it was going to happen.

I read the text and subtext, the highlights and the lowlights. I could even read all the footnotes and every single one of the script’s cues.

But I couldn’t see it as it was about to happen in my story.

I barely saw any of it.

Is that why I cannot allow myself to be fully touched by this film?

Is that why I claim it is not my story?

Because good or less good, loving or less loving, capable or less capable I might have been as a parent, “Love isn’t always enough” (*)

That simple truth that I don’t want to accept.

Even when I know it to be true.

The harsh, naked truth.

My love was not enough to keep Julia alive.

I failed. We all failed in that regard.

My love. Our love. Love. Was not enough for Julia.

(*) This is a line from the psychiatrist as he counsels the parents to keep their child in care.

About Emma Pearson

2 thoughts on “Love Is Not Always Enough

  1. Hi Emma,
    reading your commentary on the film “The Son” I feel for you.
    Your conclusion with a question mark (?): “Love just isn’t always enough”? Yes, I agree with you, but – according to my inner awareness – only half of it is true. Love can change the person you love, but it doesn’t always work.
    I loved our two children, Marcia and Dirk. But I failed because I wasn’t aware or not paying enough attention. I didn’t see my children’s inner despair, I just wasn’t awake enough to see what they were feeling inside. Who can fully recognize and appreciate the innermost part of another human being, even if he loves her or him very much? I think that’s very difficult, but of course it’s not an excuse.

    You compare the film “The Son” with your and Julia’s fate and realize that the scenes only partially correspond to your fate. The film therefore doesn’t really touch you. But is it important to recognize the differences? No, that’s not important.
    I think it’s important to accept your tragedy, nobody can change that. I can only release the feeling of guilt if I accept my children’s decision and know that it was necessary for them to act in this way. They had no way out of their despair and I couldn’t help it, despite my love.
    Thank you for your lines, reflections and feelings, they helped me.
    Dietrich

    1. thank you Dietrich – I appreciate your thoughts and reflections, and know how, with your story, just how long one can feel guilty – decades – Or choose instead to accept. Most of the time I do accept. AND the loss is so huge.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *